3 Bed
2 Bath
1,944 FT2
0.42 Acres
Built in 1935
Historic 3 Bedroom House For Sale By Owner in Nags Head, NC Mattie Midgette’s National Register Property (FSBO)
Rare opportunity to own a piece of Outer Banks history! Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, Mattie Midgette’s iconic two-story property offers an authentic Outer Banks lifestyle in the heart of Old Nags Head.
Located at Mile Post 13 on the highly desirable Beach Road, this one-of-a-kind historic property sits directly across the street from the ocean and is surrounded by other classic Nags Head cottages.
Just a short walk to Jockey's Ridge State Park, and minutes from grocery stores, restaurants, retail shops, and healthcare facilities, this home offers both convenience and coastal charm.
The property is situated on an oversized 62’ x 300’ lot (42/100 acres / 18,600 sq ft) in a peaceful, spacious setting with C-5 zoning, making it perfect for a variety of residential and commercial uses.
Approved zoning options include an owner-occupied art gallery, museum, yoga studio, home office, book store, coffee shop, or residential with accessory commercial space—ideal for entrepreneurs, creatives, and investors seeking flexible use.
This 1,944 square foot home features 3 bedrooms and 1 1/2 bathrooms, plus a rare blend of preserved historic charm and functional layout.
The interior boasts original pine tongue-and-groove paneling throughout the walls and ceilings.
The first floor includes a living room, kitchen, laundry room, utility room, pantry, half bathroom, and an original 18’ x 35’ storefront space a nod to its historic use as a local grocery store.
Upstairs, you'll find three bedrooms, a large full bath with a vintage clawfoot bathtub and a modern 4-foot stall shower, as well as a 14’ x 18’ covered deck offering “whitewater” views of the Atlantic and a panoramic overlook of the Cottage Row Historic District.
The property is a dream for history lovers, beachgoers, and anyone wanting to invest in a truly unique piece of the Outer Banks.
Whether you want to renovate it for personal use, develop an income-producing venture, or preserve a piece of Nags Head heritage, this listing offers endless potential.
Offered For Sale By Owner (FSBO).
No listing agents, please.
Buyer must be financially pre-approved prior to viewing.
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 08/19/2025 | Listing Price | $885,000 |
4008 South Virginia Dare Trail, Nags Head, NC 27959, USA, City - Dare County
3 Bedroom House For Sale By Owner in Nags Head, NC 
