3 Bedroom House For Sale By Owner in Nantucket, MA

$2,299,000
Bedroom Icon 3 Bed
Bathrooms Icon 3 Bath
Sqft Icon 1,476 FT2
Acres Icon 0.12 Acres
Calendar Icon Built in 1850

Property Description

3 Bedroom Historic Cedar Shingle Home For Sale By Owner in Nantucket, MA Includes Additional Garage & Apartment Own a piece of Nantucket history with this classic 1850 cedar shingle home located just a short walk from town.
Offered For Sale By Owner, this 3 bedroom residence has been cherished by generations of the Gardner family, one of Nantucket’s earliest settlers dating back to the 1660s.
Rich in character and island heritage, this home is perfect for those seeking an authentic Nantucket experience with modern conveniences.
In addition to the main home, the property includes a spacious 840 sq ft detached garage with a fully finished 1-bedroom, 2-bathroom apartment on the second floor ideal for guests, rental income, or extended family.
A 300 sq ft private patio offers a quiet outdoor retreat, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach or entertaining friends in the heart of the island.
Whether you're looking for a summer getaway, year-round residence, or investment property, this Nantucket FSBO home delivers unbeatable location, historic charm, and rare added value with its additional living space and garage apartment.
Schedule your private showing today and experience a timeless part of Nantucket’s legacy.

Details & Amenities


  • Heating:

  • Cooling:

  • Auxiliary SQ FT: 100

Listing History

Date Event Price
09/03/2025 Listing Price $2,299,000

Property Location

21 Mill St, Nantucket, MA 02554, USA, City - Nantucket County