This Listing Is No Longer Active

3 Bedroom House For Sale By Owner in Shelter Island, NY

$1,300,900
Bedroom Icon 3 Bed
Bathrooms Icon 2 Bath
Sqft Icon 1,700 FT2
Acres Icon 2.25 Acres
Calendar Icon Built in 2008

Property Description

3 Bedroom Post Modern Home For Sale By Owner in Shelter Island, NY Central Air, Screened-In Porch, Quiet Country Setting

Don’t miss this opportunity to own a beautifully maintained Post Modern-style home nestled on 2+ peaceful acres on a quiet country lane in Shelter Island, NY. Built in 2008, this 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers a perfect mix of modern comfort and serene surroundings just a half-mile from Wades Beach and close to Fresh Pond.

Key Features:

Spacious Great Room with open-concept layout, ideal for entertaining

Kitchen with stainless steel appliances and plenty of cabinet space

Master bedroom suite with private Jacuzzi bath

Screened-in porch perfect for relaxing outdoors in comfort

Central air conditioning throughout for year-round climate control

Set on a quiet, tree lined country lane offering privacy and tranquility

Located near Fresh Pond and just minutes to beaches, boating, and nature trails

This For Sale By Owner Shelter Island home offers a rare opportunity to enjoy all the charm and beauty of island living with the modern amenities you need. Whether you’re searching for a full time residence, summer getaway, or investment property, this home delivers both location and lifestyle.

Contact the owner directly to schedule a private showing today.

Details & Amenities


  • Heating:

  • Cooling:

  • Auxiliary SQ FT: 100

Listing History

Date Event Price
09/04/2025 Listing Price $1,300,900

Property Location

21 Lakeview Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA, City - Suffolk County